Press releases

“Implementation COP” ends without overall consensus as real economy action races ahead 

Share
55667336310_8bb5310f65_k
Hard-fought negotiations in Antalya ended without reaching consensus on an overarching outcome. Photo of the COP31 closing plenary by Kiara Worth via UNClimateChange Flickr.

Overview

Hard-fought negotiations in Antalya ended without reaching consensus on an overarching outcome and only procedural progress on some negotiation items. Against a backdrop of worsening climate impacts, geopolitical instability and a second fossil fuel-driven energy crisis in four years, COP31 failed to secure the necessary political and diplomatic leadership in the negotiations to accelerate implementation of the Paris Agreement and demonstrate the collective response needed in this era of overshoot.  

Progress on climate action and the energy transition, although under attack by fossil fuel interests in negotiation rooms, is unstoppable in the real economy as volatility and energy insecurity drive countries and sectors to seek to realise the economic benefits of clean, renewable energy and the national security implications of freeing themselves from fossil fuels. In Antalya, that momentum was clear, led by over 70 countries backing the electrification pledge, over 20 countries announcing fossil fuel transition roadmaps, and partnerships driving green industrialisation, adaptation and oceans initiatives. 

Despite the lack of overall consensus today, some progress was made, and multilateralism remains alive and essential. The UN process is the only forum where every country has a voice and is crucial for setting global goals and bringing governments and all actors together around real-world delivery as well as formal negotiations. Countries rejecting this weak deal did so as they saw this was the only way to protect the integrity of the UNFCCC, Paris Agreement and the IPCC science going forward. 

There can be no doubt this outcome shows the geopolitical strains before us – and makes the road to Addis Ababa harder – but there is also momentum happening, and a collective call to not simply agree to lowest common denominator but rather to continue to maximize the economic opportunities and necessities before us. 

Key points

  • Inadequate overall outcomes: This COP took place in a time of geopolitical strain, limited fiscal space and with weak leadership, alongside the reality of an overshoot world and mounting frustrations over the lack of adequate progress on science, finance and mitigation. In these circumstances, prospects for a high-ambition consensus outcome were always limited. A concerted pushback by some blockers including strong opposition from Russia and Saudi Arabia, together with the challenges of a joint Presidency and not enough of a plan to deliver financing added extra challenges to the dynamics. 
  • Parties rejected proposed Presidency cover decision that failed to match climate reality and real-world momentum and needs: With no reference to transitioning away from fossil fuels (TAFF), the text failed to acknowledge what is most needed, and was also in sharp contrast to the strong momentum and cross Party support building outside of negotiation rooms on the TAFF agenda at this COP. The response to overshoot and the role of science were also weakened and references to information integrity were also omitted. This undermines efforts to ensure access to reliable and trusted evidence on climate change and solutions. COP31 did however see a strong bloc of countries across the developed and developing world align around support for science and the critical need to use the best available science as core to climate action. As the 65th IPCC session resumes in December agreement must be reached on budget and timeline for AR7 reports to enable them to inform the second Global Stocktake in 2028. 
  • Negotiations advanced on some tracks and stalled on others, with some pushed to Bonn and COP32. With the cover decision absorbing political bandwidth and strains on the system on full display, the wider negotiated agenda received less attention than it deserved. Little or no new and additional money reached the table, and substantive progress on the Climate Finance Work Programme was postponed to COP32. Two tracks did deliver. The Just Transition Work Programme and the Global Goal on Adaptation was adopted with a route to establishing the technical taskforce that will refine the 59 Belém indicators ahead of COP32. Both decisions leave key questions open, including the governance of the just transition mechanism and a number for tripling adaptation finance, which return in Bonn and at COP32. 
  • Energy transition support widely signalled: There are successes, however. During this ‘implementation COP’, momentum has continued to build with over 70 countries joining the electrification pledge, and wider action on electrification delivery; the global platform for methane reduction reached 47 countries, and USD 480 million was announced to accelerate action on methane and other non-CO₂ greenhouse gases. There was an undeniably strong call for action on transitioning away from fossil fuels. With over 20 national TAFF roadmaps released or announced, and a clear path to the next TAFF Summit in Tuvalu in July, the energy transition is moving at speed, despite concerted efforts to delay by fossil fuel producers, as players seek to benefit from the economic opportunities and free themselves from dependence on volatile fossil fuels. 
  • Action Agenda showcased a broad portfolio of impact: Within the wider Action Agenda, we’ve also seen focus on green industrialisation, cutting methane emissions, halting deforestation, oceans and health action, and building resiliency to mounting climate impacts. Initiatives that delivered growing numbers of engagement with climate action from countries, cities, sectors, business, and community across the globe. Climate Weeks across the world, including London Climate Action Week, announced a shared intention to work more closely together to accelerate implementation of the Paris Agreement, demonstrate progress between COPs and support a coherent journey towards COP 32 and the second Global Stocktake through the Global Climate Action Agenda. Even without a formal acknowledgement in the final version of the proposed cover decision, this work will continue to accelerate. 
  • Finance flows critical and access is key: Investment flows into the energy transition are growing globally despite the finance COP negotiations largely kicking the can down the road without clear commitments and accountability. Access must be a priority – ensuring that the money already pledged for climate finance more generally and specifically for adaptation reaches those who need it without adding to debt. Driving adaptation finance requires a credible pathway from ambition to delivery and developed countries must reaffirm their responsibility to lead on mobilising finance, including the $300 billion NCQG commitment.  
  • The Road to Addis and Global Stocktake 2: There is no doubt that the end result of COP31 was disappointing, but this does not mean that multilateralism has failed. Multilateralism remains essential to forge common agreement and to keep the spirit of the Paris Agreement alive. The UN process remains the only forum where every country has a voice and an opportunity to shape outcomes. Over the coming years on the road to the second Global Stocktake in 2028, this process must evolve to truly support implementation and ambition. Much will rest on Ethiopia’s shoulders to take this work forward and ensure the deadlock of Antalya gets unstuck in time for Addis and the positive statement by Ethiopia setting out their priorities and vision gave a strong sense of direction and engagement by their upcoming COP Presidency. 

Quotes

Kaysie Brown, Associate Director, Climate Diplomacy & Geopolitics, E3G, said 

“Antalya faced two simple tests. Could it rally the world to answer 1.5C overshoot with support of the science and faster action on emissions, adaptation and the finance to pay for both? And could it live up to its own billing as the “COP of delivery”? Underneath both was a bigger question: can climate cooperation still hold in a fractured world? 

Antalya struggled to deliver on the first test and passed the second outside the negotiating rooms. Governments rejected a cover text that did not send the signals needed to show seriousness in responding to overshoot and the centrality of science. They should never have been forced into that choice.   

But some agreement was reached across negotiation rooms, and delivery, meanwhile, is real: this COP proved that the Action Agenda that has become the engine of implementation. Neither that progress nor the necessity of multilateralism disappears after Antalya. The UN process is still the only place where every country has a voice and laggards can be held to account. It is only as strong as the political commitment governments bring to it, and the road to Addis Ababa and in real world partnerships and investments is now where that commitment must be advanced.  

We leave Antalya unclear about what happens on critical issues such as the Antalya to Addis Ababa roadmap on adaptation finance and work on oceans, mountains, forests and beyond as well as with the upcoming IPCC resumed session and the implications for the next global stocktake.”

Cosima Cassel, Programme Lead, Climate Diplomacy & Geopolitics, E3G, said: 

“This COP was the first in the era of overshoot. Warming above the 1.5C limit is now unavoidable. The science is clear – every fraction of a degree matters to avoid the most devastating impacts of climate change. COP31 needed an urgent response which matched the scale of that challenge. In the face of significant geopolitical headwinds, stubborn blockers, a challenging Presidency setup, and attempts to undermine the science itself, we leave Antalya without a substantive negotiated outcome.   

The months ahead are decisive, starting with the IPCC’s December decisions on budget and timelines that will shape the evidence base for the second Global Stocktake. And at this crucial moment on the road to the next Global Stocktake, much now lands on Ethiopia’s desk. Ethiopia must engage early and work with the UK’s G20 presidency, through China’s BRICS presidency and with others to unblock and bridge divides. Progressive countries must engage, align and actively support that effort throughout the year if COP32 is to deliver meaningful progress on mitigation, adaptation finance and a just transition.” 

Alden Meyer, Senior Associate, Climate Diplomacy & Geopolitics, E3G, said: 

“As escalating climate impacts devastate communities and ecosystems across the world, COP31 needed to show countries coming together to confront the climate emergency. Instead, reluctance from developed countries to step up on climate finance, combined with opposition from Saudi Arabia and other petrostates to implementing the COP28 agreement on transitioning away from fossil fuels, led to a disappointing outcome. 

 Yet beyond the negotiating rooms, momentum continues to grow. Governments, cities, businesses and investors are advancing clean energy, methane action, green industrialisation, adaptation, health, oceans and forest protection through the Action Agenda. That spirit of collaboration stands in stark contrast to the adversarial dynamics that too often dominate the formal negotiations. Unlike negotiated text, these real-world initiatives cannot be vetoed by opponents of climate action.” 

Heather McKay, Programme Lead, Finance and Resilience, E3G, said: 

“While presidencies and parties are stalling, the outside world is moving at pace. This risks signalling that COP finance conversations are out of step with the real world. However, the failure to find consensus at COP31 is ultimately a call for greater ambition. The case for action is clear. Countries, development banks and the private sector are already moving ahead with efforts to finance resilience. Now we need to scale up finance and ensure that countries and communities most exposed to climate impacts can access it on affordable terms. COP31 missed the chance to set out how to scale up adaptation finance equitably, and to connect that investment with an ambitious just transition away from fossil fuels.” 

Matt Webb, Associate Director, Global Clean Power Diplomacy, E3G, said: 

“This outcome is disappointing but if we step back from the negotiating rooms and look at the real world, the shift to clean energy is irreversible—and it is gaining pace. Clean energy investment is now double that of fossil fuels, and renewables have drawn level with coal in terms of global electricity generation. 

We saw that momentum reflected in the wider Action Agenda in Antalya rather than the negotiations. Over 20 countries came forward with fossil fuel transition roadmaps, and we’ve seen major new backing for the global electrification pledge which will help drive fossil fuels from transport, cars and industry. Getting strong fossil fuel language into a consensus text is tough – but the direction of travel is unmistakable.” 

Available for comment 

Diplomacy and UNFCCC / COP processes  

Kaysie Brown (EN), E3G Associate Director, (multilateral climate diplomacy, geopolitics, US foreign policy) | e: kaysie.brown@e3g.org 

Cosima Cassel (EN, DE, ES), Programme Lead, E3G, (Multilateral venues, Climate Diplomacy and Geopolitics, UNFCCC and COP) m: +49 160 339 0883 | e: cosima.cassel@e3g.org 

Alden Meyer (EN), Senior Associate, (multilateral climate diplomacy, geopolitics, US federal & subnational policy) m: +1(202)-378-8619 | e: alden.meyer@e3g.org 

Finance 

Heather McKay (EN, FR), Programme Lead, Finance and Resilience, E3G, (Green and Transition Finance, UK, Resilience), m: +44 7955 597676 | heather.mckay@e3g.org  

EU 

Marc Weissgerber (EN, DE), Executive Director, Berlin, (Europe, Germany, Geoeconomics & Finance) m: +49 (0) 175 1974404 I marc.weissgerber@e3g.org 

Notes to editors 

  1. E3G is an independent think tank working to deliver a safe climate for all. We drive systemic action on climate by identifying barriers and constructing coalitions to advance the solutions needed. We create spaces for honest dialogue, and help guide governments, businesses and the public on how to deliver change at the pace the planet demands. About E3G 
  1. For further enquiries email press@e3g.org or phone +44 (0)7783 787 863 
  1. Register for our journalist WhatsApp briefing service to receive updates and analysis for key geopolitical and climate events: E3G WhatsApp registration for journalists

Related

Subscribe to our newsletter